Skip to Content
Call Us Today! 201-254-8484
Top

What If the Plaintiff Contacts You While a New Jersey Restraining Order Is in Effect?

Llama al 201-254-8484 Defiende tus derechos
domestic violence restraining order
|

You have been served with a New Jersey domestic violence restraining order. Then the person who obtained it texts you, calls you, or asks to meet. Perhaps they want to discuss the children, collect belongings, or reconcile.

Their willingness to communicate does not change the court’s order. If it prohibits you from contacting them, responding can expose you to a contempt charge. Start by reading the exact restrictions and any exceptions in your order.

Does the plaintiff’s permission allow you to respond?

The plaintiff cannot privately suspend or cancel a restraining order. A message saying “you can call me” or “I want to drop the case” does not amend its terms.

New Jersey Courts expressly warns that reconciliation does not automatically dismiss a final restraining order. A judge must address a request to change or dismiss it. Until then, the defendant remains responsible for complying.

The order’s wording, court-authorized exceptions, and the parties’ communications can nevertheless matter when determining whether the State can prove a purposeful or knowing violation. Preserve incoming messages for your attorney to review. An invitation to communicate does not itself create permission under the order.

What should you do with incoming messages?

Preserve the original messages, call records, and voicemails, and provide them to your attorney. They may help counsel evaluate the circumstances, a potential defense, or an application to the court.

If the order prohibits a response, avoid continuing the exchange. Asking a friend or relative to deliver your reply may also create a problem if the order prohibits indirect contact.

Even a friendly discussion about bills, returning keys, or getting back together can involve prohibited communication. The absence of threats or offensive language does not necessarily make the contact permissible.

What about children, parenting time, or belongings?

Read every provision governing communication, parenting time, exchanges, and access to property. Some orders permit a narrowly defined communication method or establish arrangements through another person. Permission for one purpose does not necessarily authorize broader conversations.

For example, an order might permit communication through a designated parenting application about the children. Follow that provision according to its terms.

If necessary arrangements are unclear, counsel can seek clarification or modification. Preserve any related parenting orders and communications so counsel can assess the full record.

Is every accidental encounter a violation?

A contempt conviction requires proof of the applicable statutory elements beyond a reasonable doubt. Under N.J.S.A. 2C:29-9(b), the State must establish a purposeful or knowing violation of a covered restraining-order provision.

An unexpected encounter in a store therefore requires examination of the facts. Relevant questions may include whether the defendant recognized the protected person, approached them, initiated communication, or knowingly remained within an area the order prohibited.

Receiving an unsolicited message and deliberately responding are different events. If an encounter or communication has already occurred, preserve the evidence and have counsel assess what happened against the order’s actual language.

Can a violation lead to criminal charges?

Yes. Under N.J.S.A. 2C:29-9(b), a purposeful or knowing violation of a covered domestic violence restraining-order provision can constitute a fourth-degree crime when the violating conduct could also constitute a crime or disorderly persons offense. Other covered violations constitute disorderly persons offenses.

Certain provisions concerning parenting time, monetary relief, counseling, and support are excluded from enforcement under that subsection. Those provisions remain enforceable through other appropriate court proceedings.

The wording of the order, the alleged conduct, and the defendant’s knowledge all matter. The plaintiff’s invitation to communicate does not itself authorize prohibited contact.

How can the order be changed?

A party may ask the Family Part to modify or dissolve the order through the appropriate court process. Under N.J.S.A. 2C:25-29(d), modification or dissolution of a final restraining order requires good cause. The deciding judge must be the judge who entered it or have the complete underlying hearing record available.

A defendant seeking dissolution must also satisfy applicable statutory requirements, including completing professional domestic violence counseling required by the order.

Obtain and review the court’s new order before acting on an anticipated change. A separate criminal case or release condition may impose additional restrictions that also require attention.

The Law Office of Louis G. DeAngelis, LLC represents clients in restraining-order and related criminal matters in Bergen County and elsewhere in New Jersey. Contact our Englewood office to discuss your order, the communications you received, and your available options.

This article provides general information about New Jersey law. Consult an attorney about your specific circumstances.

Categories: